Loading...
Head to head
Goat Funded Trader vs Take Profit Trader
Goat Funded Trader and Take Profit Tradercompared on the things that actually decide a challenge — profit split, drawdown type, the consistency rule, news and weekend trading — straight from each firm's decoded rulebook. Take Profit Trader edges ahead on FundedWiki's overall rating (8.4/10 vs 8.5/10), but the right pick depends on how you trade.
Goat Funded Trader8.4/10 · Forex
Cheap to enter and easy on targets, with lenient holding/EA/news rules — just mind the trailing instant drawdowns, the 2% floating-loss kill switch and the 30-day inactivity breach.
Best for: Swing and news traders who want lenient holding rules and cheap, low-target entry — and who respect the per-trade floating-loss cap and avoid martingale/over-leveraged 'gambling' trades.
Start a Goat Funded Trader challengeTake Profit Trader8.5/10 · Futures
Genuine day-one daily withdrawals and no consistency rule once funded — but the EOD trailing drawdown that becomes INTRADAY on the PRO account is what blows most accounts in week one of funding.
Best for: Active futures scalpers/intraday traders who want fast, frequent payouts and can respect a tight trailing drawdown — not swing traders who need overnight holds.
Start a Take Profit Trader challengeSide by side
| Rule | Goat Funded Trader | Take Profit Trader |
|---|---|---|
| FundedWiki rating | 8.4/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Type | Forex | Futures |
| Profit split | 80% – 100% | 80% (PRO) / 90% (PRO+) |
| Max drawdown | Mixed | EOD trailing |
| Consistency rule | Yes | Yes |
| News trading | Restricted | Restricted |
| Weekend holding | Yes | — |
| Min trading days | 3 days | 5 days |
| Funding models | 1-Step, 2-Step, 3-Step, Instant | 1-Step |
| Platforms | MT5, cTrader, Match-Trader | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Rithmic |
| Rules decoded | 11 | 10 |
Green = the trader-friendlier side on that row (higher rating/more rules decoded, no consistency rule, or freer news/weekend trading). Splits and facts are summarized from each decoded rulebook — open a firm for full per-rule detail and sources.
The verdict
Take Profit Trader edges ahead on FundedWiki's overall rating (8.4/10 vs 8.5/10), but the right pick depends on how you trade.
Goat Funded Trader runs the tighter rulebook, so Take Profit Trader gives most traders more room to breathe (rule-strictness 46 vs 45 on FundedWiki's 0–100 scale).
Goat Funded Trader restricts news trading; Take Profit Trader restricts news trading. If you trade the calendar, that difference alone can decide it.
Goat Funded Trader vs Take Profit Trader — FAQ
Is Goat Funded Trader or Take Profit Trader better?
Take Profit Trader edges ahead on FundedWiki's overall rating (8.4/10 vs 8.5/10), but the right pick depends on how you trade. Goat Funded Trader is best for swing and news traders who want lenient holding rules and cheap, low-target entry — and who respect the per-trade floating-loss cap and avoid martingale/over-leveraged 'gambling' trades.; Take Profit Trader is best for active futures scalpers/intraday traders who want fast, frequent payouts and can respect a tight trailing drawdown — not swing traders who need overnight holds..
Goat Funded Trader vs Take Profit Trader: which has the better profit split?
Goat Funded Trader advertises a 80% – 100% profit split; Take Profit Trader advertises 80% (PRO) / 90% (PRO+). Always confirm the current split on the firm's site before you buy — splits change with promos and scaling.
Which has stricter rules, Goat Funded Trader or Take Profit Trader?
Goat Funded Trader runs the tighter rulebook, so Take Profit Trader gives most traders more room to breathe (rule-strictness 46 vs 45 on FundedWiki's 0–100 scale).
Does Goat Funded Trader or Take Profit Trader allow news trading?
Goat Funded Trader restricts news trading; Take Profit Trader restricts news trading. If you trade the calendar, that difference alone can decide it.
Picked one? Check for a live discount first.
PropFirmDrops tracks current Goat Funded Trader and Take Profit Traderchallenge promos & discount codes.
Informational and comparison content only — not financial advice, and not affiliated with Goat Funded Trader or Take Profit Trader. Rules change often; verify against each firm's official terms before relying on any detail.